Tax evasion is about children’s rights
(MENAFN- Swissinfo) The UN Committee on the Rights of the Child should ask Switzerland to report on the extraterritorial impact of its tax policy, argues international law professor Alexandra Dufresne.
This content was published on November 6, 2021 – 10:00 November 6, 2021 – 10:00
Alexandra Dufresne teaches American law, international law and children’s rights at higher education institutions in Switzerland. She works with refugee, human rights and development NGOs in Europe and is a co-founder of ‘Action Together: ZÃ¼rich, CH’, an action group of American citizens in Switzerland.
The response to the Pandora, Paradise and Panama documents has tended to focus on the threat that tax evasion and lack of transparency pose to the ability of governments to fight corruption, ensure tax fairness and prevent money laundering. What is largely missing from the debate is the recognition of the direct impact of tax evasion on the human rights of children.
Tax evasion is fundamentally a matter of children’s rights. Children are disproportionately harmed by tax evasion facilitated by jurisdictions with low transparency standards. The realization of their most important rights – the right to education, health care, food, housing, freedom from violence and a sustainable environment – depends on the capacity of their State to origin to collect sufficient tax revenue. While adults can influence fiscal and budget priorities by voting or holding public office, children are not free to do so.
The âPandora Papersâ highlight the activities of Swiss financial advisers
This content was published on October 4, 2021 October 4, 2021 The leaked Pandora Papers expose the role of Swiss lawyers, accountants and consultants in managing the wealth of powerful clients.
Moreover, the countries where children are most severely affected by insufficient income, mostly southern states, are not the same as those which benefit most from serving as “tax havens” for multinational corporations. and wealthy individuals and families, primarily states in the Global North. The possibility of âexternalizingâ the costs of tax avoidance policies on âchildren of othersâ, especially children in low-income countries External link, makes reforms in this area very difficult.
Last month, External link, the United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child (CRC) reviewed Switzerland’s human rights record with regard to children. Although the CRC has expressed concern about the external link regarding violence and discrimination against vulnerable groups of children, overall Switzerland has performed well with regard to children on its own. territory.
But what about the extraterritorial impact of Swiss fiscal and financial policies on children abroad, for example, through their negative impact on the capacities of states External link to achieve sustainable development goals such as good health, quality education, gender equality, safe water and sanitation? A flaw in the CRC’s review process is that it does not yet systematically take into account externalities – in this case, the negative effects suffered by children (mainly in countries of the South) as a result of tax transparency policies. and financial of a reporting State. In its September 2021 reviewExternal link and October 2021 concluding observations, External link, the CRC did not investigate or raise these issues.
In contrast, the CRC recently asked Ireland External link to describe measures taken to “ensure that tax policies do not contribute to tax abuse by companies operating in other countries, which would have a negative impact on the availability of resources for the realization of children’s rights in these countries â. It is an excellent precedent. The CRC should also ask Switzerland to do so in its next periodic report, due in March 2026.
The need for more transparency
It is estimated that tax havens hold 10% of the total world GDP. Despite recent reforms, Switzerland is ranked by the Tax Justice Network as the fifth largest tax haven, responsible for $ 12.8 billion in lost revenue to other countries. (Ireland is ranked 11thExternal link). While it is home to only 11% External link of the world’s population, Switzerland is responsible for 5.1% of global tax evasion losses. It also ranks third in the world for financial secrecy. External link Efforts in parliament last spring to address some of the loopholes failed.
The changing face of international Geneva
Geneva, the original globalist city, remains a magnet for new organizations and initiatives, but it faces many challenges.
Switzerland is responsible for $ 13 billion in losses due to tax evasion around the world
This content was published on March 14, 2021 March 14, 2021 Switzerland benefits from tax abuses by businesses and individuals to the tune of approximately $ 12.8 billion according to a new global ranking.
There is a precedent for recognizing the extraterritorial effect of the Swiss fiscal and financial transparency policy on human rights. In 2016, under pressure from NGOs and academic institutions External link, Switzerland was tasked by the Committee for the Elimination of All Discrimination against Women (CEDAW) to assess and report publicly External link the extraterritorial effects of its financial secrecy and fiscal policy on women’s rights. CEDAW called for these periodic reviews to be independent, participatory and impartial. External link
But the issue has yet to receive the attention it deserves.
The most important reason is the lack of transparency itself. The complex web of policies that allow wealthy individuals and businesses to hide their wealth is complicated and opaqueExternal link. As evidenced by the Pandora, Paradise and Pentagon Papers scandals – which only came to light after data breaches – financial secrecy rules make it difficult to determine how much money is at stake or where it is flowing. Financial services advisers and tax authorities are engaged in a cat-and-mouse game in which innovative strategies for hiding wealth develop faster than the ability of governing authorities to update their laws and regulations.
In addition, understanding and investigating these transactions often falls outside the training and expertise of child rights experts and advocates, who often have training in psychology, social work, health, education and children’s law, rather than fiscal and financial law and policy. Business and human rights initiatives tend to focus on issues other than tax evasion.
“We must increase the production of Covid vaccines”
This content was published on Nov 2, 2021 Nov 2, 2021 Political scientist Daniel Warner wonders about the final choice facing Swiss citizens: whether or not to get vaccinated against the Covid vaccine.
For this reason, it makes sense to place the onus on governments to calculate and report the costs of their policies. . Governments are those who have access to relevant information. To avoid unnecessary search burdens, the CRC could start by asking the handful of jurisdictions most directly responsibleExternal link for the majority of tax evasion cases, including SwitzerlandExternal link, to report. The CRC could model its reporting requests on its 2020 requests to Ireland, as well as CEDAW’s 2016 request to Switzerland, which specifically mentions the extraterritorial impact of financial secrecy as well as tax policy.
Since a significant portion of tax evasion is committed by extremely wealthy individuals and families, the CRC should consider adding tax evasion by individuals. Perhaps more importantly, the CRC should ask Switzerland and other concerned states to produce concrete impact assessments, based on current evidence, as well as specific policies. This would reduce the risk that States Parties would avoid undertaking serious data-driven analysis and seek to “respond” to such inquiries by reference to a general report on business and human rights principles, as Switzerland appears to have done in its CEDAW 2020 submission External link.
Switzerland, like Ireland and other tax havens, must take into account the costs of its national policies of fiscal and financial transparency on children abroad. Measuring and publicly reporting these costs is the first step.
The opinions expressed in this article are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of SWI swissinfo.ch.
Articles in this story
- The âPandora Papersâ highlight the activities of Swiss financial advisers
- The changing face of international Geneva
- Switzerland is responsible for $ 13 billion in losses due to tax evasion around the world
- “We must increase the production of Covid vaccines”
Legal warning: MENAFN provides the information “as is” without warranty of any kind. We accept no responsibility for the accuracy, content, images, videos, licenses, completeness, legality or reliability of the information contained in this article. If you have any complaints or copyright issues related to this item, please contact the supplier above.